Mike 4: Social Proof
Okay, this is the last Michael Jackson related post.
As crazy and social maladjusted Michael Jackson was in his personal life, he was peerless in one area, and that was creating a larger than life showbiz persona. And the second video I posted from him, “Liberian Girl,” demonstrates this perfectly and I think has a lot of human principles to teach.
First thing to notice about the video is the use of social proof. Social Proof is a concept popularized by Robert Cialdini, author of “Influence.” It basically says that if something is endorsed by a bunch of people, it automatically rises in value to onlookers. For example if I walk into a venue and don’t say hello to anyone and no one says hello to me I will make one impression. If I walk into a venue and a bunch of people mob me and I seem to know and say hello to everyone, I have social proof. Even if I’m dressed and looking exactly the same in both examples, in the example where I have social proof my value will rise sharply. People who look on will automatically assign value to me without knowing anything about me. The quality of the people also determines the level of social proof. Anyone who has been out with an incredibly hot woman knows this to be true. Men and women both treat you differently and assign you value automatically without knowing anything about you. If you walk in someplace with a model-caliber companion or a famous person like Diddy or Donald Trump with you, the social proof will be significantly more powerful from that one person than if you walked in with a mob of 30 nobodies.
Another good example of this is rapper team-up songs and videos. The format is the same. A rapper who is popular has another rapper who is as popular or up and coming and puts him in the video. He’s endorsing his social circle and gaining social proof. He’s telling people who are watching, “This is my friend. This is the caliber of rapper I hang with. If you think he’s credible, than I am credibly too by association.” Usually the two rappers are of equal or near equal status, and use each other’s presence to mutually give each other social proof. Then as icing on the cake they surround themselves with a bevy of fine women, fancy cars and material possessions. Crude but effective.
There is a current rapper coming up named Drake who is using social proof to an incredible degree to make himself incredibly popular and viral. He’s made himself a household name among rap fans within less than a year just by hanging out, working with and appearig in public with today’s top rappers. This gave him social proofing among hip-hop’s male fans. Plus he was publicly spotted dating female celebrities like Rihanna, which gained him a lot of press and gave him social proofing among females who follow black celebrity gossip.
He used social proofing so well that his album hit #3 on Billboard and he has yet to complete an album! More incredibly, he didn’t even have a record label yet! He has since ignited one of the biggest ever bidding wars for a new artist in history:
Toronto MC Drake, arguably the most talked about up-and-coming artist since Kanye West and 50 Cent, is involved in a serious bidding war between at least three major labels according to Billboard.
As XXLMag.com reported last month, Drake is close to signing a deal, but has yet to sign on the dotted line. Billboard has learned that Drizzy will most likely go to Universal, due to the label’s relationship with his crew Young Money. At the same time, this has not deterred other labels from baiting the So Far Gone rapper, whose mixtape single “Best I Ever Had” is receiving serious radio airplay. In fact sources tell Billboard that three majors are in possibly “one of the biggest bidding wars ever.” It is rumored that an undisclosed company has offered Drizzy $2 million to join their ranks.
In addition, Warner Music Group CEO Lyor Cohen and Chief Operating Officer Julie Greenwald made a notable appearance at Drake’s New York City concert last week, showing Atlantic’s interest in the former Degrassi actor.
An astounding accomplishment for a relative unknown in an incredibly short time, accomplished primarily through social proof. In one of Drake’s mixtape songs I heard, he shouts out Robert Greene’s 48 Laws of Power as his personal bible. I’m not surprised.
However when it comes to social proof in show business, Michael Jackson was great at this, and he knew how to do it better than anyone else. It’s a lesson he learned from Berry Gordy, who used his existing stable of Motown stars to add social proof to the Jackson 5, such as when he created the legend that Diana Ross was responsible for discovering the Jackson 5, which is why their first album was named “Diana Ross presents The Jackson 5.” She had absolutely nothing to do with their discovery, but Berry Gordy created the legend that she did, and had her present them to the crowds at all their early performances and on their debut album, which even contained a written story describing this discovery that never actually occurred in real life. It’s a lesson that stayed with him throughout his life.
The “Liberian Girl” video is a prime example of this:
The video for the song came out in 1989, and it features the prime celebrities of the era: Paula Abdul, Rosanna Arquette, Dan Aykroyd, Mayim Bialik, Bubbles, Jackie Collins, David Copperfield, Emily Dreyfuss, Richard Dreyfuss, Corey Feldman, Lou Ferrigno, Debbie Gibson, Danny Glover, Steve Guttenberg, Jasmine Guy, Whoopi Goldberg, Sherman Hemsley, Olivia Hussey, Amy Irving, Malcolm-Jamal Warner, Beverly Johnson, Quincy Jones, Don King, Virginia Madsen, Cheech Marin, Olivia Newton-John, Brigitte Nielsen, Lou Diamond Phillips, Ricky Schroder, Steven Spielberg, Suzanne Somers, John Travolta, Blair Underwood, Carl Weathers, Billy Dee Williams, “Weird Al” Yankovic. Many of these stars may have faded into B or C-list obscurity since then, but at the time they were all huge names.
But putting celebrities in a video isn’t novel or exceptional as far as social proof goes. But what made this video notable wasn’t just the quantity or quality of the celebrities but the context in which they were used. What Jackson was always good at, and it started back in the Jackson 5 era with Diana Ross, is that he’s always been able to present himself as a celebrity to celebrities, or a god to other gods. This is his social proof masterstroke. He makes sure to remind you that he is the idol to your idols. He creates the impression that he’s doing them a favor by letting him appear in his video rather than giving the impression he’s using them for social proof. He has Steven Spielberg waiting anxiously in a chair for him for Pete’s sake.
That’s another notable social dominance aspect of the video. Making people wait for you and getting away with it is a display of social power, a way to remind others of dominance. It’s also a way to build anticipation and anxiety. The whole video is the era’s A-list celebrities waiting for him with bated breath with nothing to do. He sends no apologies, doesn’t send any explanations to them for where he is, they’re left in the dark and even more importantly, no one threatens to leave or get upset. They patiently put up with it. They ask where he is often, but not out of anger but anticipation.
This is also an illustration of Law 16 of Robert Greene’s 48 Laws of Power:
Law 16 Use Absence to Increase Respect and Honor
The best element is the final one, his actual arrival. Not only is it a nice subtle bit of spectacle, but for those who know classic theatre it’s highly symbolic. First, the direction he comes from. He descends from above like a god. More specifically, he descends like a “deus ex machina,” which translates to a “god from the machine”:
the ‘god from a machine’ who was lowered on to the stage by mechanical contrivance in some ancient Greek plays (notably those of Euripides) to solve the problems of the plot at a stroke.
And what does the god do once he descends from his machine to their cheers and adulation? He simply dismisses them with one sentence. He got what he needs from them without their knowing and is done with them. And they’re happy with that, so long as they get a glimpse of him. It’s incredibly arrogant, but he is able to get away with it by doing it with childlike charm and an innocent smile. The whole video is bragging without bragging, or displaying high value without explicitly having to verbally toot your own horn.
So the lessons you can learn from this video? First, use social proofing whenever you can. Even if you arrive somewhere by yourself you can use social proofing. Within seconds of walking in, walk up to a stranger, ask them some question, smile, pat them on the back, shake their hand and move on. Do this once or twice more and to onlookers you seem to casually know people. Introduce yourself to people, make small talk, exchange names, and remember them. They’ll come in handy later. When you find a person you actually want to keep talking to and engage in a longer conversation, whenever you see the other people you exchanged names with earlier, you can introduce each other. Anything to casually remind people that you know other people who like and endorse you. No one has to know that you just met these people, although even if it comes out no one really cares by that point anyway.
Also keep in mind the quality of social proofing. People of low social value, such as nerds or unattractive women or boorish, loud low-class people, if you surround yourself with them, actually provide negative social value. You’re better off being alone at that point. Also, avoid that type of friend whose preferred method of breaking ice to strangers is to crack jokes and excessively bust on his or her friends. These people are annoying and not only hurt you but themselves. People see you getting busted on and think “wow, what a loser, his own friend doesn’t respect him,” then they look at your friend and think “wow, what a loser, he doesn’t respect his own friend,” and both of you lose value. If you keep quiet you look bad, if you bust back, then you look just as much like a douche as your friend. And it elevates the stranger’s value, because he or she now has two friends taking turns bashing each other for his entertainment, even though they know each other longer and are supposed to be friends. Just like Michael Jackson used flattering words from celebrities to build up his reputation and image, you should be around friends who do the same for you. In fact, this is more important than any other part of social proof. Say for example you are someplace with a hot girl or a powerful man, which would normally give you social proof whether you are a man or a woman, and they spend the whole time berating and belittling you and cracking jokes at your expense? At that point the high quality of your companions does nothing for you.
Second, act humble but avoid self-deprecation. Michael Jackson was great at acting humble while actually having a larger than life ego and self-regard. This is the man who crowned himself “King of Pop,” much like the Stones were the first to name themselves the “World’s Greatest Rock Band.” And in the case of both MJ and the Stones, the names eventually stuck and everyone forgot who originated them. But notice that the biggest celebrities, the ones that even other celebrities look up to, almost never engage in self-deprecation. I can’t think of a time MJ, despite his soft-spoken and shy act, ever was self-deprecating. There’s only one exception to the self-deprecating rule. If you have extremely high-status, you can put yourself down and instead it comes off as endearing. In that case, the ability to still put yourself down despite your obvious high status actually improves your image. If you don’t have blatantly high status, the only acceptable self-deprecation is blatantly insincere self-deprecation. For example if you are in a bar and know everyone there, you can joke “Yeah, I’m a pretty lonely guy with no friends. Look, I couldn’t get anyone to come out tonight!” If you are a musclebound tall guy, you can say “Yeah, it sucks to be a 95 pound weakling.” Ironically, people will be impressed at how humble you are for not taking yourself too seriously in such a scenario, but if you actually were friendless or a 98 lb weakling and said the exact same thing, it would get an opposite reaction!
Third, understand that extreme lateness is a power play that elevates the status of the one being waited for and lowers the status of the one waiting. However I wouldn’t recommend people to be habitually late because it’s not only a tacky power play but often a transparent one as well. It says “I’m so important that I can show up whenever I want, and I consider your time is so unimportant that I expect you to just wait around for me.” Instead what I would tell people is, if you are being kept waiting for too long without an acceptable excuse, just leave and announce that you’ll reschedule at a better time. Don’t act angry about it and indicate annoyance, just do it matter-of-factly and without malice. Display that your time is valuable too and shouldn’t be taken for granted.
Fourth, don’t be afraid to be the most prominent person in your social circle, but don’t be an openly opportunistic dick about it. People love ambition, but hate when it appears to be too naked and aggressive a power grab. Michael Jackson didn’t want to just be a celebrity, he always aimed to be THE celebrity, even to other celebrities. But he didn’t do it by bullying and throwing his weight around. He did it by offering value to his social circle. By bringing them joy and making them value and love his presence and the other things he brought to the table, they were more than willing to give him the highest status in their circle. By not trying to be overly bullying and transparently nasty in his play to present, he reached top dog status without building up resentment and negative backlash in his peers. He framed it in a way where people felt they were being done a favor by being allowed to defer to him. A good fictional example of the opposite is the main character from “All About Eve,” who made it to the top but lost all her friends and companions at the end of the day.

Dude, this precisely why i come here: This kind of thoroughly reasoned analysis. No offense to vk, roosh, and roissy. Compare to them, you are peerless.
THIS REMINDS ME OF A POST i posted at VK…i hope you dont mind, i am taking the liberty of posting here, any advice? Here it is, repasted.
Oh well, i have awesome friends, great friends. They’ve all went through serious shit for me. They are the best. I can unequivocally say: they have my back…….Except when it comes to game. Jesus, they are super-omega/beta incarnate. Some almost put david alexander to shame.
As such, i engage three options.
#1: I roll solo.
#2: I will tell them to excuse me while i go to the bathroom and on the way back, engage my target. Even with this, sometimes, when they see me talking to a chick at a distance, they will walk over and hover like flies and sometimes, abruptly interrupt and directly displaying too much interest in the girl(staring bug-eyed, mouth agape, talking too fast, ) all directed at the prettiest one. Directly competing and trying to talk over you with the girl you are talking to.
#3 The third approach that i generally use when i am out with them is to go and round up a couple of girls for them; and transit the ladies to come and meet them; while they are engaging with those ladies, i will then find a way to extract myself so that i can approach my own target group.
My friends will ABSOLUTELY NOT LEARN game because it is “morally reprehensible”. I have spent the years trying to update them; to no avail; and the usually annoying complaint that is constantly leveled at me: that i over-think male/female dynamics; but then, they turn around and want me to bring girls to them all the time. On the flipside,they will probably donate their fucking kidneys for me if i need it. So, there is my dilemna. I wont throw them away.
Anyways. I roll solo, and/or bring them girls and detach myself to actually approach my target group. that is my current modus operandi.
I am far more interested in how you build a winging team from scratch. Because of my current situation. This will significantly help me. Let us face it, not everybody that wants to hang with you because you are smooth with the ladies, automatically qualifies. What are the telltale signs of a potentially worthy apprentice? How do you go about building a team?
Exceptional post. Great insight and reason.
Ralph´s last blog ..Top 7 Fear Factors that Prevent People from Starting a New Business. (Guest Post)
This is a great post, even though the only Michael Jackson I have any interest in is the guy who reviews expensive beers.
About the blatant self-deprecation – the more blatant the better. If you’re that big muscular guy, don’t just complain about being too skinny or people might start to think you actually think that and are obsessive getting even bigger (as some big muscular guys are). Complainining about being a specific weight when you’re obviously at least twice that works much better.
T,
Masterful post.
You are really one of the few cats out there that can do a long blog post, keep someones attention, and make great points.
- MPM
The G Manifesto´s last blog ..The Del Mar Racetrack Checklist
Two things T.:
The first is “social proof” is extremely risky. It’s not the same if you walk into a room and everyone says whats up to you and you seem to know everyone but when a woman who’s interested in you asks about you, noone can vouch for you because they all only know you superficially. Or if you walk into the restaurant with a smoking hot model on your arm, but she was on the arm of some other man last week. And another the week before that.
Drake is proof of this. He came out a star and he was hot shit for a few weeks but when he broke his hip or whatever happened, he had nothing to fall back on. Nobody is talking about their favorite Drake classic or how he changed the game. If he ever comes back out, he has to start FROM SCRATCH. He has to regenerate the buzz, recapture people’s attention or partner with some even bigger rappers.So superficial social proofing is good for the quickie but for the long term, you still need to build up some kind of track record.
Second, the kind of social proofing Michael Jackson did in that video could only be done by Michael Jackson. Youre right, one sure way to lose respect is to be late. I don’t care who you are or what your stature was before you came late, you just took a credibility hit. You could be my boss and I will call you on it and if you’re being a dickhead and trying to make some kind of power thing out of it, I will hand you your first loss. Time is a contract. People that are always late are literally untrustworthy. Especially when they always have a reason why they’re late or some mysterious and unforeseen circumstances that thru no fault of their own makes them unable to stay on time.
Oh and – You know who did impress the hell out of me with his display of social proof? Jamie Foxx.
I can’t explain why but Jamie Foxx had to really, really, really grow on me. I didn’t even like him on “In Living Color”. I didn’t find his comedy funny and he looked weird to me. The first time he earned my respect as an actor was in “Ray”. He and the lady that played the mother killed that movie. I don’t know which came out first but when I saw “The Kingdom” after that, I was already sold but he became my favorite actor like now, I’ll go see a movie just because Jamie Foxx is in it.
Then he came out with Blame It on The Alcohol and I liked that song. But when I saw the video though, it was like oh shit. Jamie Foxx is BIG. He parties with Ron Howard? Quincy Jones? Jake Gyggenhall? How the hell does he know Jake Gyggenhall? Enough to be chilling with him? Is that Samuel Jackson up in the cut? No competition with him, they’re both just cooling out? Forest Whittaker getting light? Damn, this looks like a fun party. Jamie Foxx is kicking it to the beautiful chic but the video is not about that, he’s dancing with everybody, laughing with some Black men that look like his people From Before the Money. He’s wearing the dog hat, getting the two girls to kiss, letting his sister rock because he’s not ashamed of her illness and he still is cool enough that she wanted to come party with him, and at the end of the night, he has the dog head from the costume in his hands exhaling like that was fun and I’m tired. The girls is nowhere in sight like it wasn’t even about that. He was having fun.
Moral of the story therefore: Jamie Foxx is as cool as s**t. A night with Jamie Foxx and you’re going to drink, laugh, dance, meet other cool people, do things you didn’t think you’d do and at the end of the night, it’ll be something to remember.
And- even though it was a lot of other people not in the video, with the caliber of people he did have in there, it stuck out like a sore thumb that Will Smith was nowhere in sight. Got you thinking. Maybe Will Smith is not cool? Maybe Will Smith could have never went from talking to the beautiful girl to dancing with the drunk girls to chilling in the VIP with Ron Howard and Samuel Jackson? Maybe Will Smith could have never made a record so good that he made T-PAIN (capitalized because its unbelievable) bearable? And not only did he make the previously unbearable TPain bearable but he bought out the best in him and TPain came off smoother than the mack. “Took another sip and opened up like a book, but I ain’t trippin’…cause I’m gonna read ya.” T-Pain? Talking like you could sit down and explore deep thoughts with him? Sick!!!
He took social proofing to the next level with that video.